Most manufacturers start with spreadsheets, QuickBooks, and a patchwork of apps. It works, until it doesn't.

As SKUs multiply and orders surge, these disconnected systems buckle. Inventory visibility blurs. P&Ls drift. Double entry becomes a full-time job.

Enter ERP. But picking the right ERP and getting it implemented correctly isn’t easy. Poor setups fracture data, obscure margins, and trigger costly rework.

This guide helps you:

• Compare the best ERP inventory systems for mid-sized manufacturers

• Understand why most ERP go-lives fail (and how to avoid it)

• Learn from real-world recovery stories

• Run a self-audit to assess your setup

• Discover why Cin7 + Fiskal may be your most strategic move

1. The hidden cost of staying on Excel

2. What ERP systems work for $5M-$50M manufacturers?

At this growth stage, companies often rely on cobbled systems:

• QuickBooks or Xero + Excel trackers

• Entry-level inventory tools like Fishbowl or Katana

• Disconnected EDI, 3PL, and forecasting apps

This patchwork fuels sync errors, decision lags, and chargeback risks. For example, if your EDI integration falters, you could oversell inventory or miss shipping windows, leading to costly penalties and damaged partner trust. Seamless EDI isn’t a luxury in manufacturing; it’s a lifeline.

Here’s a deeper look at each ERP option, followed by a summary table:

Cin7 Core

Best for: Growing manufacturers managing multiple warehouses and complex BOMs.
Price: Starts around $349/month
Deployment: Cloud-based
Overview: Cin7 Core (formerly DEAR) combines inventory, order, warehouse and accounting integrations in one cloud platform. It’s designed to give real-time visibility of SKUs, warehouse movement, and cost tracking without full enterprise overhead.

Key features:

• BOM management and job costing

• Multi-warehouse and 3PL integration

• Landed cost tracking

• Native Xero/QuickBooks sync

Pros:
✔ Excellent inventory-finance alignment
✔ Affordable for mid-market teams
✔ Modular add-ons for POS, 3PL, and marketplaces
✔ Real-time sync between inventory and accounting for accurate COGS
✔ Advanced landed-cost tracking for true margin visibility
✔ Scales across warehouses and channels without enterprise overhead
✔ Fast 6–10-week go-live with guided, finance-aligned setup

Cons:
✘ Setup complexity increases as workflows become more advanced
✘ UI can feel rigid for advanced customization

Cin7 Omni

Best for: Mid-sized manufacturers also selling D2C via marketplaces/retail.
Price: Custom / higher tier
Deployment: Cloud-based
Overview: Cin7 Omni builds on Core with POS, marketplace, and advanced retail functionality; ideal when manufacturing and direct sales channels operate in parallel.

Key features:

• POS + marketplace order flow

• Multi-channel inventory control

• Unified reporting

• Finance-inventory continuity across sales paths

Pros:
✔ Combines retail + manufacturing in one platform
✔ Inventory accuracy across all selling points

Cons:
✘ More complexity, more cost
✘ Longer implementations

Fishbowl

Best for: Manufacturers on QuickBooks needing stronger inventory/manufacturing without full ERP.
Price: Mid-tier
Deployment: On-prem or cloud
Overview: Fishbowl gives SMBs a scalable way to manage inventory and manufacturing without switching from QuickBooks.

Key features:

• Work orders and multi-step builds

• Sub-assembly BOMs

• Inventory across locations

• QuickBooks/Xero sync

Pros:
✔ Budget-friendly ERP-lite
✔ Popular for first-time manufacturing automation

Cons:
✘ Limited scalability
✘ Less flexible reporting/customization

NetSuite

Best for: Scaling manufacturers with global ops or deep finance needs.
Price: High; custom
Deployment: Cloud
Overview: NetSuite is a true ERP: finance, inventory, CRM, supply chain all in one. Ideal for global or enterprise-grade manufacturers.

Key features:

• BOM, work orders, planning

• Global inventory

• Financials with consolidation

Pros:
✔ Complete ERP functionality
✔ Multi-entity, multi-currency

Cons:
✘ Expensive, time-intensive rollout
✘ Overkill for smaller teams

Katana

Best for: Small-to-mid manufacturers needing simplicity, speed, Shopify sync
Price: Starts ~$179/month
Deployment: Cloud
Overview: Katana is a light MRP system with strong DTC support—great for fast-moving product brands with basic manufacturing needs.

Key features:

• Drag-and-drop production scheduling

• Live inventory of materials/products

• Shopify/Xero/WooCommerce sync

• BOM support

Pros:
✔ Quick to onboard
✔ Great UX
✔ Low entry cost

Cons:
✘ Light on financial features
✘ Customization is limited
✘ Not built for scale

DOSS ERP

Best for: Manufacturers needing configurable workflows and scalable ERP without enterprise pricing.
Price: Mid-range, usage-based
Deployment: Cloud-based
Overview: DOSS ERP offers flexible workflow automation, inventory tracking, and production management features built for manufacturers scaling past spreadsheets but not yet enterprise-size.

Key features:

• Work order management and production routing

• Inventory across multiple warehouses

• Vendor management and approvals

• Custom workflow automation

• QuickBooks and Shopify integrations

Pros:
✔ Modular and scalable for growing manufacturers
✔ Good workflow automation tools
✔ Responsive support for mid-sized teams

Cons:
✘ Smaller app ecosystem
✘ Requires expert setup to unlock full customization

Want to compare DOSS to Cin7 and others? Read our head-to-head ERP comparison for scaling brands →

Finale Inventory

Best for: Manufacturers and distributors needing rapid implementation and flexible barcode-driven workflows.
Price: Mid-range, based on users and orders
Deployment: Cloud-based
Overview: Finale Inventory is a lightweight, barcode-first inventory system used by ecommerce manufacturers or warehouse-heavy teams.

Key features:

• Barcode scanning and mobile stock control

• Order and supplier management

• Light manufacturing support (basic builds, kitting)

• Multichannel ecommerce integration

• QuickBooks integration

Pros:
✔ Extremely fast to implement
✔ Great for barcode-based warehouses
✔ Ideal for ecommerce brands

Cons:
✘ Limited advanced manufacturing tools
✘ Lacks deep financial reporting or native BOM costing

Looking for alternatives to Cin7 for ecommerce and warehouse-heavy teams? Explore our ERP solutions guide →

ERP summary table

Pro Tip: For many $5M–$50M manufacturers, Cin7 Core + Omni offer the best cost-to-capability ratio, especially when implemented by an ops-savvy, finance-first partner like Fiskal.

ERP failure isn’t about software. It’s about skipping the hard stuff: process mapping, data prep, and team training.

Common Pitfalls:

• No clear ownership of BOMs, SKUs, or reporting

• Inventory and finance are misaligned

• Rushed implementations that skip testing

Real-world fix:

Case Study: emergency vehicle fitting company
Before: Paper quotes. Warehouse blind to inventory. No margin visibility.
After: Fiskal implemented Cin7 Core with clean BOMs, job costing, and training.
Result: Real-time visibility and accurate, confident quoting.

3. Why ERP projects fail (and how to avoid it)

Use this checklist to spot hidden friction:

❌ Inventory counts don’t match sales reports
❌ Manual PO entry still dominates
❌ Syncs with Shopify, 3PL, or EDI fail often
❌ No clear owners for BOMs or reporting

4. ERP health check: is your setup holding you back?

Safety First Emergency Vehicles
Paper quotes, inventory confusion → Real-time control with Cin7 Core and Fiskal

Ghurka (luxury leather goods)
Disconnected systems, bad reports → Clean Cin7 Core + Xero setup, unified data

Wilson Manifolds (auto parts)
Bookkeeping chaos → Repeatable systems and trained teams

5. ERP recovery stories: real results with Fiskal

Not all ERP issues require starting over. Use this framework:

✅ When to rebuild:

• BOM, sales, or procurement workflows are broken

• Chart of accounts can't be reconciled

• Vendor customizations limit functionality

🔧 When cleanup works:

• Core processes are intact but messy

• Data is salvageable

• Training or syncs are the main issue

Example: A packaging manufacturer had reporting gaps and slow warehouse syncs. Initially thinking they needed a full rebuild, Fiskal’s audit revealed that the core workflows were sound. With targeted data cleanup, EDI sync repairs, and ownership training, they avoided a costly overhaul and regained control within weeks.

6. Fix or rebuild? How to decide

Why Cin7 + Fiskal = strategic ERP success

Cin7 offers a modular, cloud-based ERP that’s well-suited for manufacturers navigating the complexity of multi-warehouse inventory, EDI, and real-time margin tracking. It’s a scalable solution that supports growing operations, but its true potential is only unlocked when paired with expert implementation. Without the right setup, companies often encounter phantom inventory from BOM misconfigurations, misallocated landed costs, and unreliable financial reporting due to disconnected charts of accounts.

This is where Fiskal comes in. Rather than approaching ERP as a software install, Fiskal aligns the system with your actual workflows, bridging operations and finance so the ERP reflects how your business really runs. Their team delivers role-based training tailored to your staff, ensures go-lives hit milestones, and stays engaged post-implementation through quarterly health checks. Case studies prove it: for mid-market manufacturers facing data chaos or unclear margins, Fiskal’s partnership turns ERP frustration into operational clarity, confidence in quoting, and a reliable system that grows with you.

Final word: don't just "go live." Go long-term.

ERP is your company's nervous system. It's not just a tech install, it's a strategic enabler that requires continuous attention.

Most ERP challenges arise not from the initial setup, but from neglecting long-term optimization. Regular audits, user training, and alignment between finance and operations are key to realizing full ROI.

That’s why Fiskal offers quarterly ERP health checks, to ensure your system evolves with your business and stays aligned with your strategic goals.

Set your team up for clarity, not chaos.

Next steps

Book a 30-minute ERP system audit, with zero-pressure clarity on what's working and what's not, or explore Cin7 optimization with Fiskal. From cleanup to rebuild, Fiskal can guide the way.

📞 Or call us directly: (954) 415-7895

Share on your socials.